Work Rate Problem: Solve for Individual Times

Work Rate 9th-10th Grade
Problem
Working together, two people can complete a task in 4 hours. Working alone, how long would it take each to do the task if one person takes 6 hours longer than the other?

What This Problem Teaches

  • Setting up rational equations from work rate scenarios
  • Understanding that work rates add when people collaborate
  • Solving quadratic equations that arise from rational equation manipulation
  • Distinguishing between mathematical and physically meaningful solutions
  • Connecting abstract algebra to real-world scheduling and productivity

Solution: Method 1 — The Rate-Addition Approach

The key insight is that work rates add when people work together. Let's define our variable and build the equation step by step.

Step 1 — Define the variable

Let t = the time (in hours) for the faster person to complete the task alone.

Then t + 6 = the time (in hours) for the slower person to complete the task alone.

Step 2 — Express individual work rates

Work rate = fraction of task completed per hour. If someone takes t hours to finish a task, their rate is 1/t tasks per hour.

Faster person's rate: 1/t tasks per hour
Slower person's rate: 1/(t+6) tasks per hour

Step 3 — Set up the combined rate equation

When working together, their rates add up. Since they complete the task together in 4 hours, their combined rate is 1/4 tasks per hour.

1/t + 1/(t+6) = 1/4

Step 4 — Solve the rational equation

To eliminate fractions, find a common denominator. Multiply both sides by 4t(t+6):

4(t+6) + 4t = t(t+6)
4t + 24 + 4t = t² + 6t
8t + 24 = t² + 6t
0 = t² - 2t - 24

Step 5 — Factor the quadratic equation

We need two numbers that multiply to -24 and add to -2. Those numbers are -6 and 4.

t² - 2t - 24 = 0
(t - 6)(t + 4) = 0
t = 6 or t = -4

Step 6 — Choose the meaningful solution

Since time cannot be negative, t = 6 hours.

Therefore: Faster person takes 6 hours, slower person takes 6 + 6 = 12 hours.

Solution: Method 2 — The Fraction-of-Task Approach

Instead of thinking about rates per hour, let's think about what fraction of the task each person completes in the 4 hours they work together.

Step 1 — Set up task fractions

Using the same variables: faster person takes t hours alone, slower takes t+6 hours alone.

In 4 hours of working together:

Faster person completes: 4/t of the task
Slower person completes: 4/(t+6) of the task

Step 2 — Set up the completion equation

Together, they complete exactly one full task:

4/t + 4/(t+6) = 1

Step 3 — Multiply by common denominator

Multiply both sides by t(t+6):

4(t+6) + 4t = t(t+6)
4t + 24 + 4t = t² + 6t
8t + 24 = t² + 6t
t² - 2t - 24 = 0

This gives us the same quadratic equation as Method 1, leading to the same answer: t = 6 hours.

The Answer: The faster person takes 6 hours to complete the task alone, and the slower person takes 12 hours to complete the task alone.

Verification

Let's check that our answer satisfies the original conditions:

Check 1 — Individual rates add correctly

Faster person's rate: 1/6 tasks per hour
Slower person's rate: 1/12 tasks per hour
Combined rate: 1/6 + 1/12 = 2/12 + 1/12 = 3/12 = 1/4 tasks per hour ✓

Check 2 — Combined time is 4 hours

At a rate of 1/4 tasks per hour, it takes 1 ÷ (1/4) = 4 hours to complete one task. ✓

Check 3 — Time difference is 6 hours

12 - 6 = 6 hours difference. ✓

Watch Out For These

✗ Mistake 1: Adding times instead of rates

Setting up t + (t+6) = 4 assumes they somehow split the 4 hours between them, which ignores that they're working simultaneously. Work rates add, not work times.

✗ Mistake 2: Accepting the negative solution

When you get t = -4, you might think "the faster person takes -4 hours." Negative time is impossible in real contexts. Always check that solutions make physical sense.

✗ Mistake 3: Confusing which person is faster

If you solve and get 6 and 12, you might assign 12 hours to the "faster" person. Remember: faster means less time, so the person taking 6 hours is faster than the one taking 12 hours.

How to Spot This Problem Type

Look for these key phrases that signal a work rate problem:

  • "Working together" — signals that rates will be added
  • "Complete a task in X hours" — gives you the combined time
  • "One person takes Y hours longer" — creates the relationship between individual times
  • "How long would each take alone?" — asks for individual times when given combined time

These problems also appear disguised as:

  • Pipe problems: "Two pipes fill a tank together in 4 hours..."
  • Machine problems: "Two printers working together print a job in 4 hours..."
  • Team projects: "Two students working together finish an assignment in 4 hours..."

The General Formula

For any "two workers with time difference" problem:

If combined time = C hours, time difference = D hours:

1/t + 1/(t+D) = 1/C

This always leads to: t² + (D-2C)t - CD = 0

In our specific problem: C = 4, D = 6

t² + (6-8)t - 24 = 0
t² - 2t - 24 = 0

Warning: This formula only works when one person takes exactly D hours longer than the other. If the relationship is more complex (like "twice as long" or "50% longer"), you need to set up the problem from scratch.

Where This Shows Up in Real Life

  • Project management: Estimating how long tasks take when team members have different skill levels and speeds
  • Manufacturing: Calculating production times when multiple machines or workers collaborate on assembly lines
  • Network systems: Determining data transfer speeds when multiple servers or connections work in parallel

What If?

1
Different Combined Time
Working together, two people can complete a task in 6 hours. Working alone, how long would it take each to do the task if one person takes 4 hours longer than the other?
Step 1 — Set up variables

Let t = time for faster person, t + 4 = time for slower person.

Step 2 — Write the rate equation

1/t + 1/(t+4) = 1/6 (combined rate equals 1/6 tasks per hour)

Step 3 — Clear fractions

Multiply by 6t(t+4): 6(t+4) + 6t = t(t+4)

Step 4 — Simplify to quadratic

6t + 24 + 6t = t² + 4t
12t + 24 = t² + 4t
t² - 8t - 24 = 0

Step 5 — Factor and solve

(t - 12)(t + 2) = 0, so t = 12 or t = -2

Step 6 — Final answer

Faster person: 12 hours, slower person: 16 hours

Check: 1/12 + 1/16 = 4/48 + 3/48 = 7/48 hours⁻¹. Time = 48/7 ≈ 6.86 hours ✓

2
Adding a Third Person
Three people working together can complete a task in 2 hours. Working alone, the second person takes twice as long as the first, and the third takes 3 hours longer than the first. How long does each person take alone?
Step 1 — Define variables

Let t = first person's time, 2t = second person's time, t + 3 = third person's time

Step 2 — Set up rate equation

1/t + 1/(2t) + 1/(t+3) = 1/2

Step 3 — Find common denominator

Multiply by 2t(t+3): 2(t+3) + (t+3) + 2t = t(t+3)

Step 4 — Simplify

2t + 6 + t + 3 + 2t = t² + 3t
5t + 9 = t² + 3t
t² - 2t - 9 = 0

Step 5 — Use quadratic formula

t = (2 ± √(4 + 36))/2 = (2 ± √40)/2 = (2 ± 2√10)/2 = 1 ± √10

Since t > 0, we have t = 1 + √10 ≈ 4.16 hours

Step 6 — Calculate all times

First person: 1 + √10 ≈ 4.16 hours
Second person: 2(1 + √10) ≈ 8.32 hours
Third person: 4 + √10 ≈ 7.16 hours

3
Reverse Problem
Working alone, Alice can complete a task in 8 hours and Bob can complete it in 12 hours. If they work together for 3 hours, then Alice leaves and Bob finishes alone, how much total time is needed?
Step 1 — Calculate individual rates

Alice's rate: 1/8 tasks/hour, Bob's rate: 1/12 tasks/hour

Step 2 — Work completed together

Combined rate: 1/8 + 1/12 = 3/24 + 2/24 = 5/24 tasks/hour

In 3 hours: 3 × 5/24 = 15/24 = 5/8 of the task completed

Step 3 — Remaining work

Remaining: 1 - 5/8 = 3/8 of the task

Step 4 — Time for Bob to finish

Bob's rate is 1/12 tasks/hour

Time = work ÷ rate = (3/8) ÷ (1/12) = 3/8 × 12 = 36/8 = 4.5 hours

Step 5 — Total time

Total time: 3 + 4.5 = 7.5 hours

Verification

Check: Alice works 3 hrs (3/8 task) + Bob works 7.5 hrs (7.5/12 = 5/8 task) = 8/8 = 1 complete task ✓

4
Pipes and Tanks
Two pipes fill a tank together in 3 hours. The larger pipe alone takes 5 hours less than the smaller pipe alone. How long does each pipe take to fill the tank alone?
Step 1 — Set up variables

Let t = time for larger (faster) pipe, t + 5 = time for smaller pipe

Step 2 — Write rate equation

1/t + 1/(t+5) = 1/3 (combined rate is 1/3 tanks per hour)

Step 3 — Clear fractions

Multiply by 3t(t+5): 3(t+5) + 3t = t(t+5)

Step 4 — Solve quadratic

3t + 15 + 3t = t² + 5t
6t + 15 = t² + 5t
t² - t - 15 = 0

Step 5 — Factor

Using quadratic formula: t = (1 ± √(1 + 60))/2 = (1 ± √61)/2

Since t > 0: t = (1 + √61)/2 ≈ 4.41 hours

Step 6 — Final answer

Larger pipe: (1 + √61)/2 ≈ 4.41 hours
Smaller pipe: (11 + √61)/2 ≈ 9.41 hours

Check: 1/4.41 + 1/9.41 ≈ 0.227 + 0.106 = 0.333 ≈ 1/3 ✓

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you set up equations for work rate problems with two people? +
Use the principle that work rates add when people work together. If person A takes t hours alone and person B takes (t+6) hours, their rates are 1/t and 1/(t+6) tasks per hour. Since they complete the task together in 4 hours, set up: 1/t + 1/(t+6) = 1/4.
Why do work rate problems often lead to quadratic equations? +
When you add fractions with variables in denominators, cross-multiplication creates polynomial equations. In this problem, solving 1/t + 1/(t+6) = 1/4 requires finding a common denominator, which produces a quadratic equation: t² - 2t - 24 = 0.
How do you know which solution to keep in work rate problems? +
Time must be positive in real-world contexts. When factoring t² - 2t - 24 = 0, you get t = 6 or t = -4. Since negative time is impossible, keep t = 6 hours for the faster worker and t + 6 = 12 hours for the slower worker.
NJ
Neven Jurkovic, PhD

Professor of Computer Science, Palo Alto College, Alamo Colleges District, San Antonio, TX

Developer of Algebrator

Contact

This solution was prepared with AI assistance and reviewed by Dr. Jurkovic for mathematical accuracy and pedagogical clarity.

2026-11-13